by
stompyrobot
@ 2008/08/03 - 15:19:23
Finally, relatively recently, the price of the first season of Torchwood dropped to a point wherein it was worth paying for. Of course, 'worth paying for' is a moveable feast, and your mileage may vary.
I was lucky enough to catch most of the episodes on BBC2 when they were first aired, and at the time, it was fresh, new, and interesting. Torchwood seemed to be cleverly done, with good new concepts brought to the already existing Whoniverse.
And, watching them week by week - or back to back on BBC3 - meant that the episodes were necessarily spaced out, meaning that, although they had their own internal continuity, by the time the next episode appeared you'd had enough time to process, file and forget the previous one.
However, having watched most of the episodes over this weekend, I have come to an inescapable conclusion.
Torchwood suck at their jobs.
Seriously. It's not even in a funny way. I have had trouble finding a single situation over the first season where Torchwood have made the situation in any way better by their presence. And so, reader - because, to be fair, there's only likely to be one or two of you - I present the combined Torchwood Fatality Index and Darkness Counter.
Episode 1
Deaths: Stabbing Victim, Hospital Porter, at least two previous stabbing victims, and two members of the Torchwood Team - one suicide, one murder. Very very dark, especially emphasising the corruption of team members through misuse of artifacts. Torchwood help in no way - in fact, it's one of their own who's been on a murder spree.
Episode 2
Deaths: Six or seven - at least - Deaths by Sexing. Seriously. If Joss Whedon advanced the equation in Buffy and Angel that sex = bad, this is the equivalent of that formula squared. None of these deaths would have happened had Gwen been given rudimentary training in Not Throwing Chisels at Colleagues. Torchwood only, in fact, manage to solve the problem because Captain Jack is just so chock full of energy.
Episode 3
A relatively death-lite episode, but, still, Torchwood manage to cause an accidental murder by Gwen - a fully trained Police Officer - not being able to (A)Put a knife out of harm's reach and (
Hold a knife so that someone rushing towards her won't impale themselves on it.
Episode 4
But don't worry, they're back on form for this; two deaths, both of which were caused by Ianto's inability to mention to everyone that he has a potentially planet-threatening machine in the basement wired up to his cyberwoman girlfriend, who loves him, and killing, in apparently equal measure. Along with impromptu brain surgery. Ianto also swears to let Jack die if he has the opportunity to save him, which is odd considering not three episodes later he and Jack are having Stopwatch Sex Shenanigans.
Episode 5
Deaths: a mixed grab-bag involving a paedophile, a fairy expert, and a stepfather, culminating in a mother losing both her fiancée and her only child on the same day to fairies from the dawn of time. Torchwood don't, in any way, help, and Jack spends most of the episode being cryptic and having flashbacks to another time in his life where everybody around him ends up inexplicably dead. Viewers may begin to see a pattern emerging.
Episode 6
Don't even start on this one; before the episode begins, Torchwood note that 17 people have gone missing in the same area, which tells us that Torchwood will only turn up after at least 16 people have disappeared, not before. Death abounds; in the opening section, a woman is killed for forgetting to take her car keys with her when she investigates what looks like a body in the road. This is contagious; Owen forgets to remove the keys from the SUV filled chock-full with expensive equipment, but not before the team discover a skinned corpse. Which was only, apparently, a diversion to steal the car. Quite an extreme diversion, really, but hey, who are we to judge?
Gwen gets shot but - crucially - can still operate; there's another skinned corpse in the row of houses in the middle of nowhere that they investigate; Toshiko and Ianto discover a fridge full of body parts, and are then led to a room with human corpses hanging, ready to be butchered; Gwen manages to screw up a Mexican Standoff, previously thought an impossibility; And Jack saves them all by shooting randomly in the most Darkplace-esque moment I think I've seen, before he and Gwen settle down to interrogate the main cannibal, who looks disturbingly like Frank Kelly, leading to the moment when, as he leans forward to tell Gwen why he does the whole Eating People thing, I was half-expecting him to say "DRINK! FECK! ARSE! GIRLS!"
Which might have been an improvement. Torchwood don't actually help at any point, they simply serve to get the horrible cannibals who've been doing what they do every ten years for god knows how long into police custody. Because that'll work.
Episode 7
A tricky one, this; the death at the beginning is not, strictly speaking, anything to do with Torchwood. However, Tosh discovers her inner lesbian, much to the delight of fanboys everywhere, and Jack, lacking any particular inspiration, then sends Toshiko's new girlfriend to the middle of the sun, as she turns out to be an exiled alien criminal. For once, none of this is actually Torchwood's fault, but at the same time, most of the team are too busy flirting to be of any use whatsoever.
Episode 8
Another slight anomaly; a serial killer is killing victims - three, to be precise, so far - because of Torchwood, but they don't know why. So, naturally, they decide to bring back the team member who killed herself in episode 1, because this is the logical course of action. Except that Gwen manages to develop the ability to use something she's never used before to such a degree that she begins to die so that Suzie can live. In the end, Suzie dies again, which certainly has novelty value, and the serial killer locked in the cell in the basement is never. mentioned. again. Also, the team are saved by Emily Dickinson.
An otherwise impressive, sinister, dark episode is derailed in the last few minutes by Ianto apparently having forgiven Jack over the course of the past four episodes for killing the only woman he loved to the degree that he now wants to have The Sex with Jack, to the beat of a stopwatch.
Episode 9
One death, largely because nobody in Torchwood would pay attention to Eugene, and wacky hi-jinks ensue. However, Eugene, who has been invisible and incorporeal throughout the episode, overcomes these difficulties for around two minutes to save Gwen; just long enough so that every single person at his wake can see him standing, seemingly alive, before he disappears in a flash of light. Yet, not surprisingly, this isn't commented on.
Episode 10
Three time-tossed refugees end up in 2007. The trauma of this causes one to kill himself, one goes to London and is never heard of again, and one is so in love with Owen that she decides to leave him forever by flying back into the rift. So, one death - technically two, though, as Captain Jack has a fetish for dying and coming back. It's his thing.
Episode 11
One man dies because he commits Suicide by Weevil, and his body is dumped in a warehouse; Owen poses as a Jellied Eels salesman and meets an estate agent who's also, co-incidentally, Tyler Durden; and Gwen trys to get her boyfriend to forgive her having an affair, before using an amnesia pill to make him forget she had said anything. Owen then attempts to also commit Suicide by Weevil, but is saved, before Tyler manages to do so because Captain Jack seems to think it's easier to let him kill himself than for Torchwood to arrest him. Morality's great, huh, kids?
Owen is now so brutal and manly that he can make Weevils back down by hissing at them and baring his teeth, which may come in handy at parties.
Episode 12
Torchwood are separated across 67 years, and a very dapper time-traveller manages to trick them into doing exactly what he wants just by being very dapper. If it seems like nobody's dying this episode, it's because they're saving it up for the next episode,
Episode 13
People start to realise that Owen opening the rift in the previous episode may have caused lots of problems, largely because it has. Lots of people succumb to the Black Death, but are saved, fortunately. The dapper man from the previous episodes stabs Gwen's boyfriend because he can, killing him; Owen later shoots Captain Jack dead because of an inferiority complex; their actions release Abaddon, who kills lots of people just because they're in his deadly shadow. Jack then - having risen again from the dead - kills Abaddon because, as in episode 2, he's just chock-full of life. Except he's not, any more. Oh wait! He is. Lucky, that. And instead of waiting and explaining, Jack hears the Tardis, and runs off like a giddy schoolgirl.
*
Don't get me wrong. I like Torchwood. It's just very very dark, grim television, and almost every single episode involves deaths caused by, or indirectly involved with, Torchwood. They're just, in the end, not very good at their jobs, because, in the end, who can be trained to do what they do? But, at the same time, when an agency's nominal tagline ends up as "Torchwood: If you're lucky, they won't make it worse", what more can you expect?